Previous business/academic article Next business/academic article
Business Articles Awards > Procedure

Deciding Between Bench and JuryTrial: Reflections After US Airways v. Sabre

Charles Diamond, Sergei Zaslavsky, Antitrust, Fall 2017, at 27

See Charles Diamond's resume See Sergei Zaslavsky's resume

Vote for this articleHelp

* Average
** Interesting
*** Good
**** Excellent
***** Must receive an Award!

Please note that the star(s) appearing on the article page before you have voted reflect the status of all votes registered to date.

Readers’ vote will close on February 9, 2018. Readers’ vote will allow you to nominate 1 article for each of the Awards, i.e., 10 Academic articles, 10 Business articles, and the best Soft Laws. The readers’ short-list of Academic and Business Articles will be communicated to the Board together with the 20 articles nominated by the Steering Committees. The Board will decide on the award-winning articles. Results will be announced at the Awards ceremony to take place in Washington DC on the eve of the ABA Antitrust Spring Meeting on April 10, 2018.

Click here to read the full article online

Antitrust bench trials are rare enough in this “Age of Settlement.” Trying an antitrust case to a jury is rarer still. When lawyers have to choose between a jury or bench trial, they debate endlessly whether their chances improve or diminish before one or the other. In antitrust cases particularly, the conventional wisdom holds that economic and business complexities put most disputes beyond the intellectual reach of the average lay jury; that defendants can count on getting a fair shake only when a judge decides the merits; and that plaintiffs prefer juries because the plaintiff uniquely stands to benefit from the con- fusion that arises from competing economic testimony, debates over unfathomable concepts like relevant market, and the seemingly intemperate things that business people put in emails when discussing the merits of competition they face. And everyone assumes that a jury will award damages more generously.

Download our brochure