The effects of private damage claims on cartel activity: Experimental evidence

The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, Olivia Bodnar, Melinda Fremerey, Hans-Theo Normann and Jannika Schad, 7 August 2021

Click here to read the full article online

Private damage claims against cartels may have negative effects on leniency: whereas whistleblowers obtain full immunity regarding the public cartel fines, they have no or only restricted protection against private third-party damage claims. This may stabilize cartels. We run an experiment to study this issue. Firms choose whether to join a cartel, may apply for leniency afterward, and then potentially face private damages. We find that the implementation of private damage claims reduces cartel formation but makes cartels indeed more stable. The negative effect of damages is avoided in a novel setting where the whistleblower is also protected from damages (JEL C90, L41, L44).

Authors

Testimonials

Alexandre Cordeiro Macedo
Brazilian Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE) (Brasilia)

Brazil 4 contributions 2537 visits

The Antitrust Writing Awards must be congratulated for its initiative of promoting the exchange of knowledge and research in competition policy. It was an unparalleled opportunity to be a member of the Board and present the Best Soft Law category. I feel honored and I commend Concurrences for organizing such an important endeavor.
Christian Bovet
University of Geneva

Switzerland 6 contributions 20783 visits

Participating in the steering committee is an excellent opportunity to learn each time more about competition law, not only about its substance and trends, but also about the great diversity of this ever evolving matter. The Awards ensure the continuing renewal of authors and sources.
Inge Graef
University of Tilburg

4 contributions 5128 visits

The Antitrust Writing Awards illustrate the variety of topics and ideas in the competition community. They offer an excellent insight into current academic thinking and policy developments.
Mel Marquis
Monash University

Italy 8 contributions 4207 visits

The Antitrust Writing Awards, established over a decade ago, are still going strong. The broad range of contributions and award winners this year reflect the staggering richness of legal and economic studies in this field.
David J. Gerber
Chicago-Kent College of Law

United States 7 contributions 5686 visits

Nicolas Charbit, his Concurrences team, and their Antitrust Writing Awards project provide immensely valuable service to antitrust lawyers and scholars everywhere. They give form, force and impetus to competition law thinking and to relationships within the competition law community.